A NAS can hold years of photos, documents, and media, so a second copy matters when a drive wears out or a volume fails. The best backup hard drives for nas use splits into two roles: internal drives that live inside the NAS and external USB drives that hold a separate copy outside it. This guide compares five drives for both roles.

Quick verdict

For most home and small office NAS owners, WD Red Plus and Seagate IronWolf are the clearest internal choices, while WD My Book is the most direct external target for a second copy. Toshiba N300 suits larger bays, and Seagate Backup Plus Hub for Mac fits a simple desktop backup role.

The two roles do different jobs. Internal NAS drives sit in the NAS enclosure, run around the clock, and work in RAID arrays that spread data across several drives. External USB drives plug into the NAS or a computer, hold a separate copy, and can be stored apart from the main unit. A plan that uses both roles gives a working copy and a second copy that does not share the same enclosure.

WD Red Plus stands out for NAS systems with up to 8 bays, with NASware firmware and RAID error recovery control listed by the maker. Seagate IronWolf matches it on workload and adds IronWolf Health Management and AgileArray. Toshiba N300 reaches up to 22TB and lists support for up to 12 bays, while WD My Book reaches up to 26TB with backup software and 256-bit AES encryption.

Product Type Best for Key spec Main limit
WD Red Plus Internal 3.5-inch NAS drive NAS systems with up to 8 bays 6TB model: 5400 RPM, up to 180MB/s, 256MB cache 6TB model runs at 5400 RPM, not 7200 RPM
Seagate IronWolf Internal 3.5-inch NAS drive Always-on NAS use in 1 to 8 bays 4TB model: 5900 RPM, 180MB/s, 64MB cache 4TB model cache is 64MB
Toshiba N300 Internal 3.5-inch NAS drive Larger NAS arrays with up to 12 bays Family: up to 298MB/s, up to 1GB cache, 7200 RPM Top transfer and cache figures are family maxima
WD My Book External USB desktop drive USB backup target for a NAS Up to 26TB, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 256-bit AES encryption Needs mains power through an AC adapter
Seagate Backup Plus Hub for Mac External USB desktop drive Simple desktop backup target for a NAS 4TB and 8TB models, 2-year limited warranty Maker does not state a transfer speed

How we selected

We started from the two roles in the keyword: internal drives built for NAS use and external drives that can hold a NAS backup as a second copy. Each product below comes from a maker page opened for this article, and every figure with a unit comes from that page.

For internal drives, the deciding traits were recording method, workload rating, bay support, vibration handling, error recovery control, and support for 24×7 or 24/7 operation. All three internal drives here use CMR recording and list a workload rating of 180TB per year. Those traits matter for RAID use, where drives work together for long periods.

For external drives, the deciding traits were capacity range, connection type, included software, encryption, and the physical size and weight that decide where the drive can sit. WD My Book lists USB 3.2 Gen 1, backup software, and password protection with 256-bit AES encryption. The Seagate Backup Plus Hub for Mac lists 4TB and 8TB models, a length of 198.1 mm, and a weight of 1060 g, and the maker does not state a transfer speed for that model on the opened page.

Backup hard drives for NAS compared

The five drives below cover both sides of NAS backup: three internal drives that live inside the enclosure and two external drives that hold a separate copy. Each section gives the figures the maker lists, explains who the drive suits, and notes the limits that should shape the choice.

WD Red Plus

WD Red Plus is an internal 3.5-inch drive family built for RAID-optimized NAS systems, with capacities from 2TB to 12TB and NASware firmware listed by the maker. The 6TB model WD60EFPX lists 5400 RPM, up to 180MB/s, and 256MB cache, with CMR recording and a SATA connection. It suits a home or small office NAS with up to 8 bays.

The maker describes WD Red Plus as designed for 24×7 operation in RAID-optimized NAS systems with up to 8 bays, and lists RAID error recovery control and RV sensors for the family. The workload rating is 180TB per year, and the MTBF is 1M hours. The maker lists a 3-year limited warranty, and the operating temperature range is 0 to 65 degrees C. The 6TB model measures 5.79 inches x 4 inches x 1.03 inches and weighs 750 g.

Family maxima reach up to 7200 RPM and up to 260MB/s, but those figures describe the family at its top end, not the 6TB model. The maker lists the 4TB model WD40EFPX in the 256MB cache group on the page.

  • CMR recording, SATA connection, and 3.5-inch form factor for NAS bays
  • NASware firmware with RAID error recovery control and RV sensors
  • 180TB per year workload rating and 1M hours MTBF listed by the maker
  • Designed for 24×7 operation in systems with up to 8 bays
  • 3-year limited warranty and operating range of 0 to 65 degrees C
  • 6TB model runs at 5400 RPM, below the family maximum of 7200 RPM
  • 6TB model transfer rate tops out at 180MB/s, below the family maximum of 260MB/s
  • Capacity range tops out at 12TB, below the larger families in this guide

Buy this drive if you run a NAS with up to 8 bays, want CMR recording with NASware firmware and RAID error recovery control, and want a 3-year limited warranty. Skip this drive if you need a capacity above 12TB or support for more than 8 bays in one enclosure.

Seagate IronWolf

Seagate IronWolf is an internal 3.5-inch NAS drive family that reaches up to 16TB, with IronWolf Health Management and AgileArray listed by the maker. The 4TB model ST4000VN008 lists 5900 RPM, a maximum sustained transfer rate of 180MB/s, and 64MB cache. It suits always-on NAS use in systems with 1 to 8 bays.

The maker lists CMR recording, a SATA 6Gb/s connection, a workload rating of 180TB per year, an RV sensor, dual-plane balance, and error recovery control for the 4TB model. The MTBF is 1,000,000 hours, and the load and unload cycle rating is 600,000 cycles. Average operating power is 4.8W, idle power is 3.95W, and standby and sleep power are 0.5W and 0.5W. The maker lists a 3-year limited warranty and an operating temperature range of 5 to 70 degrees C.

The 4TB model measures 26.11 x 101.85 x 146.99 mm and weighs 610 g, and the maker lists shock ratings of 80Gs and 300Gs. The maker describes the family as designed for 24×7 performance.

  • CMR recording with SATA 6Gb/s and support for 1 to 8 bays
  • RV sensor, dual-plane balance, and error recovery control
  • 180TB per year workload, 1,000,000 hours MTBF, and 600,000 load and unload cycles
  • IronWolf Health Management and AgileArray listed for the family
  • Low idle power of 3.95W and a 3-year limited warranty
  • 4TB model cache is 64MB, below the larger cache figures in this guide
  • 4TB model runs at 5900 RPM, below the 7200 RPM drives in this guide
  • Operating temperature starts at 5 degrees C, so cold rooms need care

Buy this drive if you want an always-on NAS drive with CMR recording, a 180TB per year workload rating, and health management features. Skip this drive if you want a larger cache at the 4TB size or a capacity above 16TB in one drive.

Toshiba N300

Toshiba N300 is an internal 3.5-inch NAS drive family that reaches up to 22TB, with capacities that include 4TB and steps at 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18, 20, and 22 TB. The maker lists 7200 RPM, CMR recording for all capacities, and a SATA 6Gbit/s connection. It suits larger NAS arrays where capacity and bay count both need room to grow.

The maker lists a sustained transfer rate of up to 298MB/s and a cache of up to 1GB, and both figures are family maxima, not figures for one capacity such as the 4TB model. The workload rating is up to 180TB per year, and the MTTF is up to 1.2M hours. The maker lists support for up to 12 bays, RV sensors, NASLink technology, and error recovery control, with a 3-year limited warranty and design for 24/7 operation.

That wide capacity range and support for up to 12 bays suit a NAS that may add drives over time. The 7200 RPM spindle speed also suits arrays that move large files, such as video archives and full system images.

  • Capacity range up to 22TB, with a 4TB model in the family
  • 7200 RPM with CMR recording for all capacities listed by the maker
  • Family transfer rate of up to 298MB/s and cache of up to 1GB
  • Support for up to 12 bays, with RV sensors and NASLink technology
  • Workload rating of up to 180TB per year and MTTF of up to 1.2M hours
  • Top transfer and cache figures are family maxima, not 4TB model figures
  • Higher spindle speed can mean more heat and vibration in tight bays
  • Large top capacity may exceed the needs of a small two-bay NAS

Buy this drive if you run or plan a larger NAS with up to 12 bays, want a wide capacity range up to 22TB, and value 7200 RPM with CMR recording. Skip this drive if you only need a small array or want per-model transfer and cache figures for the exact capacity you plan to buy.

WD My Book

WD My Book is an external USB desktop drive that works as a backup target for a NAS, with capacities up to 26TB and a 4TB model WDBBGB0040HBK-NESN listed by the maker. It connects through USB 3.2 Gen 1 and includes Acronis True Image for Western Digital software. It suits a second copy beside the NAS.

The maker lists password protection with 256-bit AES encryption, a 3-year limited warranty, and a format of exFAT with support for Windows 10 and later and macOS 11 and later. The drive measures 5.48 inches x 1.93 inches x 6.72 inches and weighs 1 kg. The box includes a SuperSpeed USB-A cable rated at 5Gbps and an AC adapter, so the drive needs mains power and a spare USB port on the NAS or on a computer that can reach the NAS.

As a NAS backup target, the My Book holds a copy separate from the drives inside the NAS enclosure. That separation matters when the NAS itself has a fault or when a copy needs to move to another location for storage.

  • Capacity range up to 26TB, with a 4TB model listed by the maker
  • USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection with a SuperSpeed USB-A cable rated at 5Gbps
  • Included Acronis True Image for Western Digital software
  • Password protection with 256-bit AES encryption
  • 3-year limited warranty and exFAT format for Windows and macOS
  • Needs mains power through the included AC adapter
  • Desktop size and 1 kg weight make it less suited to travel than a portable drive
  • Single external enclosure holds one copy, so it is not a RAID array by itself

Buy this drive if you want a large external USB target for a NAS backup, value included backup software and 256-bit AES encryption, and have mains power and a USB port free near the NAS. Skip this drive if you need a bus-powered portable drive or an internal drive for a NAS bay.

Seagate Backup Plus Hub for Mac

Seagate Backup Plus Hub for Mac is a desktop external drive that can serve as a USB backup target for a NAS, with 4TB and 8TB models listed by the maker. The 4TB model is STEM4000400 and the 8TB model is STEM8000400. It suits a simple second-copy role where capacity needs are modest and the drive stays in one place.

The maker lists a length of 198.1 mm and a weight of 1060 g, and lists a 2-year limited warranty. The opened page does not state a transfer speed for this model, and it does not state hub features or Time Machine support, so this guide does not claim any of those traits. That gap matters when comparing external drives, because a buyer who needs a stated speed should look for a model where the maker lists it in plain terms.

Used as a NAS backup target, the drive holds a copy outside the NAS enclosure, which gives the backup plan a second location for the same data. The 8TB model doubles the capacity of the 4TB model, so a growing library can pick the size that fits with room to spare.

  • 4TB model STEM4000400 and 8TB model STEM8000400 listed by the maker
  • Desktop external form for a fixed backup target near a NAS
  • Length of 198.1 mm and weight of 1060 g listed by the maker
  • 2-year limited warranty listed by the maker
  • Maker does not state a transfer speed on the opened page
  • Maker does not state hub features or Time Machine support on the opened page
  • Capacity range tops out at 8TB, below the larger external drive in this guide

Buy this drive if you want a simple desktop external target for a NAS backup, the 4TB or 8TB size fits your current volume, and a 2-year limited warranty meets your needs. Skip this drive if you need a stated transfer speed or a capacity above 8TB.

Buying guide

A NAS backup plan works best when the buyer starts with the data, not the drive. Count the current volume, add room for growth, and then pick internal drives for the array and an external drive for the second copy. The sections below cover capacity, speed, RAID, bays, and backup habits.

Capacity planning for backup hard drives for NAS

Capacity planning starts with the size of the data that needs a second copy, plus room for new files over the next few years. A backup drive that matches the current volume exactly will fill up fast, while a drive with generous headroom can hold several backup versions.

Match the internal drive size to the array plan, not to a single drive. For the external target, pick a size that can hold the full NAS volume at least once, with room for the next round of files.

Internal NAS drives versus external USB backup targets

Internal NAS drives and external USB drives serve different roles, and a strong backup plan uses both. Internal drives live in the NAS bays, run around the clock, and work in RAID arrays that keep the NAS running when one drive has a fault. External drives hold a separate copy that can survive a fault in the NAS enclosure itself.

Think of the internal array as the working copy and the external drive as the second copy. The working copy needs CMR recording and a workload rating that fits daily use, while the second copy needs enough capacity and a connection the NAS can use.

Workload, cache, and transfer speed

Workload, cache, and transfer speed describe how a drive handles sustained use, and the three internal drives in this guide share a workload rating of 180TB per year. That figure suits a NAS that backs up files every day. Cache and transfer speed vary by model and by family, so read the exact model figures before comparing two drives.

The WD Red Plus 6TB model lists 5400 RPM, up to 180MB/s, and 256MB cache, while the family maxima reach up to 7200 RPM and up to 260MB/s. The Seagate IronWolf 4TB model lists 5900 RPM, a maximum sustained transfer rate of 180MB/s, and 64MB cache. The Toshiba N300 lists family maxima of up to 298MB/s and up to 1GB cache, with 7200 RPM across the family.

RAID, bays, and 24/7 operation

RAID, bay count, and round-the-clock operation decide which internal drive fits a given NAS. WD Red Plus lists support for systems with up to 8 bays, Seagate IronWolf lists 1 to 8 bays, and Toshiba N300 lists up to 12 bays. A two-bay NAS can use any of the three families in this guide.

All three internal families list features for RAID use, including error recovery control and vibration handling through RV sensors. WD Red Plus lists NASware firmware, Seagate IronWolf lists IronWolf Health Management and AgileArray, and Toshiba N300 lists NASLink technology.

Encryption, software, and backup habits

Encryption and backup software turn a drive into a useful second copy, and habits decide whether that copy stays current. WD My Book lists password protection with 256-bit AES encryption and includes Acronis True Image for Western Digital software. The other external drive here does not list those traits on the opened page.

Set a backup schedule that runs often enough to catch new files, and keep the external target connected or stored where it can be reached for the next run. Label the external drive and check from time to time that the backup job still completes.

FAQ

These questions cover the choices that come up most often when planning a NAS backup: how much capacity to buy, whether an external drive can back up a NAS, why CMR matters, how many bays to plan for, and when to replace a drive. Each answer sticks to the figures the makers list and to the habits that keep a backup plan working.

How much capacity do backup hard drives for NAS need?

Capacity needs start with the size of the NAS volume that must be copied, plus room for growth and for more than one backup version. A drive that only just holds the current volume will fill up as new files arrive. The families here reach 12TB, 16TB, 22TB, and 26TB, so most volumes can find a size with headroom.

For the internal array, pick a capacity that fits the RAID plan and stays available if more drives are added later. For the external target, pick a size that can hold the full volume in one pass, because a full backup is simpler to run and simpler to restore.

Can an external USB drive back up a NAS?

An external USB drive can serve as a backup target for a NAS when the NAS has a USB port and backup software that can write to an external volume. WD My Book lists a USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection and includes backup software, which fits that role. The Seagate model here is a desktop external drive that can hold a separate copy in the same way.

The key point is separation: the external copy lives outside the NAS enclosure, so it can survive a fault that affects the internal drives or the NAS unit itself. Keep the external drive connected for scheduled jobs, or connect it on a regular schedule.

Do I need CMR drives for NAS backup?

CMR recording suits NAS use because it writes data in a way that fits RAID arrays and sustained workloads, and all three internal drives in this guide list CMR recording. WD Red Plus lists CMR, Seagate IronWolf lists CMR, and Toshiba N300 lists CMR for all capacities.

A drive that uses a different recording method may still work in some roles, but the makers in this guide present CMR as the NAS choice for their families. When comparing drives, read the recording method on the maker page for the exact model.

How many bays should my NAS have for backup?

Bay count depends on how much capacity the NAS must hold and whether the array should keep running when one drive has a fault. A two-bay NAS can hold a mirrored pair, while a larger NAS can spread data across more drives and hold more capacity. WD Red Plus and Seagate IronWolf list support for up to 8 bays, and Toshiba N300 lists up to 12 bays.

Plan for growth as well as for the current volume. A NAS with spare bays can add a drive later without replacing the drives already in place, while a NAS that is already full needs a larger drive or a new enclosure to grow.

How often should I replace a NAS backup drive?

There is no single replacement date that fits every drive, because use, heat, vibration, and workload all affect how long a drive lasts. The makers list workload ratings of 180TB per year, MTBF or MTTF figures, and limited warranties of 3 years for most models.

Use those figures as planning guides, not as promises about a single drive. Watch for warning signs from the NAS, such as errors during a backup or a drive that drops out of the array, and replace a drive that shows repeated errors while the second copy is still in place.

Conclusion

WD Red Plus and Seagate IronWolf cover most home and small office NAS arrays, Toshiba N300 suits larger bays up to 12, and WD My Book gives the plan a large external second copy. Pick internal drives for the array, add an external target for the second copy, and keep the backup schedule running so the copy stays current.

Related guides

Browse all Buying Guides guides →